C1CEFRSpeaking20 min

Class activity: The Peltham Ledger (Sugar Tax Debate)

Sugar taxes and public health

Add to my libraryFree for teachers. You sign in only when you add the lesson.

Answers and an explanation for each question appear once you add this activity to your own library.

C1 Advanced • Public Health & Economics

THE PELTHAM LEDGER

Sugar tax: gains, costs and trade-offs

🥤
Activity Length
20 Minutes
🟦 RULES OF THE GAME
👩‍🏫

For Teachers

  1. 1 Set up class into pairs and hand out the card set, phrase strip, and sentence sheet.
  2. 2 Explain the Peltham town context: an invented town introducing a new tax on sugary drinks.
  3. 3 Walk round while pairs sort the cards and write. Help with the phrases.
  4. 4 Instruct pairs to swap sentence sheets for peer checking and score calculation.
  5. 5 Use the Teacher Key at the end of this page to check the columns and the phrases.
🎓

For Students

  1. 1 Sort all 6 Peltham Ledger cards into the empty Gains and Costs columns.
  2. 2 Choose 3 different trade-off phrases from the purple phrase strip.
  3. 3 Write 3 complete sentences joining 1 Gain and 1 Cost (rephrase the Cost into a noun or -ing form).
  4. 4 Score points: 1 pt per card correctly placed, 1 pt per correct sentence, +1 bonus per Unit word used! One partner in each pair keeps the score.
  5. 5 Swap sheets with another pair to count final scores and crown the winner.
🟧 TIMED PLAN (20 MINUTES TOTAL)
2m

Step 1

Hand out cards and introduce Peltham town.

3m

Step 2

Pairs sort G1–G3 & K1–K3 into Gains vs Costs.

6m

Step 3

Draft 3 sentences joining Gains and Costs with trade-off phrases.

4m

Step 4

Add Unit words from the word bank for bonus points.

3m

Step 5

Swap sheets with another pair and calculate scores.

2m

Step 6

Check with the Teacher Key, then ask the closing questions.

🍋 CARDS, COLUMNS & PHRASE STRIP

🂠 Peltham Ledger Cards (Shuffled)

Gain Slips ➕
🍲

The tax pays for school meals.

School Meals

G1
Cost Slips ➖
💸

A family with little money pays more for its usual drink.

Family Budget

K1
Gain Slips ➕
🧪

Drink companies put less sugar in their recipes.

Lower-Sugar Recipes

G2
Cost Slips ➖
🏪

Small shops lose some customers to the next town.

Shops Lose Customers

K2
Gain Slips ➕
🥤

Families buy fewer sugary drinks.

Healthier Habits

G3
Cost Slips ➖
🏭

A few factory workers lose their jobs.

Jobs at Risk

K3

📊 Classification Ledger Columns

GAINS (➕)

Write the numbers of the 3 gain cards here:

____ (Write Gain Card IDs...)
COSTS (➖)

Write the numbers of the 3 cost cards here:

____ (Write Cost Card IDs...)

🏷️ Trade-Off Phrase Strip

Select 3 different phrases for your sentences
at the expense of to the detriment of at the risk of in exchange for in return for
💡 Sentence Frame: Gain Card Action / Fact + Trade-Off Phrase + Cost Card as Noun or -ing Form
📝 SENTENCE SHEET

Join 1 Gain card and 1 Cost card per sentence using a different phrase from the purple strip. Transform the Cost card into a noun phrase or -ing form.

Sentence 1 (Gain + Phrase + Cost): Target: 1 Gain + 1 Cost
____ (e.g., The tax pays for school meals at the expense of families with little money.)
Sentence 2 (Gain + Phrase + Cost): Target: 1 Gain + 1 Cost
____ (e.g., The tax cuts sales of sugary drinks to the detriment of small shops.)
Sentence 3 (Gain + Phrase + Cost): Target: 1 Gain + 1 Cost
____ (e.g., Families buy fewer sugary drinks at the risk of putting a few factory workers out of work.)
🟩 SCORING SYSTEM
1 Pt / Card
Sorting Precision

1 point for each card correctly sorted in Gains or Costs (Max 6 pts).

1 Pt / Sentence
Grammar Accuracy

1 point per sentence using the trade-off phrase correctly with 1 Gain & 1 Cost (Max 3 pts).

+1 Bonus / Word
C1 Unit Vocabulary

1 bonus point for each Unit word used correctly (each word counts once).

⭐ Unit Vocabulary Word Bank (1 Bonus Point Each):
excise surcharge reformulate regressive dietary nutrition preventable sugary refined lobbying
🤝 Peer Check Rule: Another pair checks and tallies your final score sheet!
🟪 SENTENCE STARTERS

Use these starters. Finish each one with a cost, using the phrase shown or one from the strip.

Starter 1

"Introducing an excise tax on sugary drinks can improve public health..."

Starter 2

"Soft drink makers may agree to reformulate their recipes in return for..."

Starter 3

"Fewer preventable illnesses and better dietary habits may come..."

Starter 4

"Even with lobbying against the new surcharge, councils may go ahead for the sake of..."

Starter 5

"Critics claim that taxes on refined sugar are regressive..."

Starter 6

"A tax on sugary drinks may improve child nutrition at the cost of..."

⬛ TEACHER KEY
Correct Gains Column

Gains: G1, G2, G3

Correct Costs Column

Costs: K1, K2, K3

Modeled Key Sentences (Accept Any Sensible Pair):

1. "The tax pays for school meals at the expense of families with little money."
2. "The tax cuts sales of sugary drinks to the detriment of small shops."
3. "Families buy fewer sugary drinks at the risk of putting a few factory workers out of work."
⚠️ Common mistakes to check
  • at the expense to ➔ at the expense of
  • to the detriment to ➔ to the detriment of
  • at the risk to lose ➔ at the risk of losing / at the risk of + Noun phrase
🪸 VARIATIONS
Level 1: Easy / With help Support

Before writing, put the cost cards on the board as noun phrases (for example K1: a family with little money paying more for its usual drink).

Level 2: Standard C1 Core

Run the standard game as described: pairs sort all 6 cards, select 3 different phrases, write 3 sentences, and execute peer scoring.

Level 3: Hard / Advanced Challenge

Every sentence must use at least two Unit words.

Extension: Fast Groups Fast Finishers

Fast pairs write a 4th sentence: is the Peltham tax good or bad for the town overall? Use a different phrase.

🌸 CLOSING QUESTIONS

Conclude the activity with these 3 debrief discussion points:

1

Do the public health benefits of Peltham's sugar tax outweigh the economic costs to low-income families?

2

How can governments prevent sugar taxes from feeling regressive to low-income households?

3

Is corporate lobbying against sugary drink surcharges justified, or should child nutrition always take priority?

Related lessons