C1CEFRSpeaking20 min

Class activity: The Brindle Debate

Children and advertising

Add to my libraryFree for teachers. You sign in only when you add the lesson.

Answers and an explanation for each question appear once you add this activity to your own library.

C1 Advanced • 20 Mins • Children & Advertising Brindle Town Council Debate

The Brindle Debate

Match each concession with a reply, then say it aloud in pairs.

📘

Rules of the Game

👨‍🏫

Teacher Instructions

  1. 1 Set up student pairs and hand out blue Concession cards and orange Reply cards.
  2. 2 Introduce the Brindle Town Council debate motion: "No advertising aimed at children."
  3. 3 Monitor pairs closely as they match cards C1–C4 to R1–R4 based on logical rebuttals.
  4. 4 Ensure students perform spoken debate turns using the 4 green Opening Frames.
  5. 5 Guide peer scorekeepers using the official Teacher Key at the bottom of the page.
🎓

Student Rules

  1. 1 Goal: Correctly match all 4 concession cards to their corresponding reply cards.
  2. 2 Roles: Partner A holds Blue Concession cards; Partner B holds Orange Reply cards.
  3. 3 Read your concession card aloud using an Opening Frame; your partner answers with the reply card.
  4. 4 Earn 1pt per match, 1pt per correct grammar turn, plus +1 bonus point per C1 Unit word used!
  5. 5 Have an adjacent pair verify and sign off on your points on the Turn Sheet.
⏱️

Timed Plan (20 Minutes Total)

2m
Step 1

Hand out the cards and state debate motion.

4m
Step 2

Pairs match Concession cards to Reply cards.

5m
Step 3

Pairs speak each turn using green Frames.

4m
Step 4

Scorekeepers tally & swap to cross-check.

3m
Step 5

Teacher reveals Key & reviews slips.

2m
Step 6

Class wraps up with Closing questions.

📺

Concession and Reply Cards

📺 Brindle Town Council Debate Motion

"No advertising aimed at children."

Concession Cards (Partner A)

📺 Concession C1
🧸

A cartoon mascot is harmless on its own.

Points to argument
📺 Concession C2
📺

Advertisers pay for many children's programmes.

Points to argument
📺 Concession C3
👨‍👩‍👧

Parents can choose which channels children watch.

Points to argument
📺 Concession C4
🥦

Adverts can teach children about new foods.

Points to argument

Reply Cards (Partner B - Shuffled)

💬 Reply R1
🪙

But a small public fee could pay instead.

Counter argument
💬 Reply R2
🍬

But one healthy-food advert sits among many for sweets.

Counter argument
💬 Reply R3
🗣️

But children pester their parents to buy what the mascot sells.

Counter argument
💬 Reply R4
🪧

But adverts are also on posters and shop shelves.

Counter argument

🧩 Task 1: Match Each Concession Card to Its Logical Reply

Tick the Reply card (R1–R4) that answers each Concession card (C1–C4):

ConcessionR1R2R3R4
C1: Mascot
C2: Funding
C3: Channels
C4: New Foods
🔗

Opening Frames

Use each opening frame exactly once during your debate turns:

F1 For all ... , ...
F2 With all ... , ...
F3 Granted, ... . Even so, ...
F4 ... . All the same, ...

📝 Turn Sheet (tick each turn after you say it)

Turn 1 (F1) Card pair: ____ + ____
Turn 2 (F2) Card pair: ____ + ____
Turn 3 (F3) Card pair: ____ + ____
Turn 4 (F4) Card pair: ____ + ____
🏆

Scoring

1 pt Per Correct Match

4 logical card pairs total (Max 4 pts)

1 pt Per Spoken Turn

Grammar used correctly + reply truly answers

+1 Bonus Per C1 Unit Word

Accurate context & pronunciation

👥
Another Pair Checks

Another pair checks and verifies score entries before submitting to the teacher.

Checker Signature:
✍️

Sentence Starters

Finish each sentence, out loud or on paper. The highlighted words are Unit words.

1. For all the catchy jingles on TV, ...

2. With all the high-profile celebrity endorsements, ...

3. Granted, marketers use clever gimmicks. Even so, ...

4. Impressionable children often pester their parents. All the same, ...

5. For all the rules about the 9pm watershed, ...

6. With all the clever persuasion used on gullible viewers, ...

🔑

Teacher Key

📍 Official Card Matches

Pair 1 C1 ↔ R3
Pair 2 C2 ↔ R1
Pair 3 C3 ↔ R4
Pair 4 C4 ↔ R2

🗣️ Model Spoken Sentences

F1 (C1 + R3):

"For all its charm, a mascot makes children pester their parents."

F2 (C2 + R1):

"With all the advertising money, a small public fee could pay instead."

F3 (C3 + R4):

"Granted, parents can choose the channels. Even so, adverts are also on posters."

F4 (C4 + R2):

"Adverts can show children new foods. All the same, one healthy advert sits among many for sweets."

⚠️

A Common Mistake

❌ Incorrect: Granted, ..., even so ... (Using a comma only between clauses is wrong!)
✅ Correct: Granted, ... . Even so, ... (Must use a full stop before starting Even so.)

🔀

Variations

Level 1 🟢

Easy (Preparation)

Pairs pre-assign frames F1–F4 to matched card pairs in writing before beginning spoken debate turns.

Focus: Accuracy
Level 2 🟡

Medium (Vocab Expansion)

Require students to incorporate at least 2 C1 Unit words into every debate turn to earn turn points.

Focus: Range
Level 3 🔴

Hard (Speed Round)

30-second timer per debate turn! Students must formulate concessions and rebuttals without pause.

Focus: Fluency
Extension ⚡

For Fast Groups

Create a counter-rebuttal turn using a second concession frame to keep the debate going for a second round!

Focus: Spontaneous Reply
💬

Closing Questions

1

Which opening frame felt most natural for a formal debate?

Say a turn with "For all..." and then with "Granted...". Which one sounds more formal when you say it?

2

Do you think a total ban on advertising to children is realistic?

Consider public funding, digital media, and enforcement challenges.

3

How do marketers exploit impressionable young audiences in modern media?

Reflect on cartoon mascots, catchy jingles, social media endorsements, and gimmicks.

Related lessons