C1CEFRSpeaking25 min

Class activity: The Bad News Call (Delivering Bad News)

Delivering bad news and refusing

Add to my libraryFree for teachers. You sign in only when you add the lesson.

Answers and an explanation for each question appear once you add this activity to your own library.

C1 Business Communication Game

THE BAD NEWS CALL

Practise giving bad news on the phone (25 Minutes)

📞
Target Level: C1
Pair Activity
25 Mins Total
📋

Rules of the Game

For Teacher

Set-up & Class Management

  1. 1 Print and prepare the Call Cards in advance so each pair gets Call 1 and Call 2.
  2. 2 Pair up students and assign Student A as the Caller and Student B as the Listener for Round 1.
  3. 3 Hand out the scoring section to Listeners before starting each phone call.
  4. 4 Run Round 1 for 7 minutes, then swap roles completely for Round 2 (7 minutes).
  5. 5 Guide students to verify scores against the Teacher Key posted on the board.
For Students

Gameplay & Winning Points

  1. 1 Your goal is to deliver unwelcome news clearly, politely, and with genuine empathy.
  2. 2 Callers must strictly follow all 5 steps in the Caller Checklist during the call.
  3. 3 Use the target grammar frames to avoid making empty or unrealistic promises.
  4. 4 Listeners react naturally and tick off completed steps on their scoring sheet.
  5. 5 Swap roles in Round 2, tally your final scores, and see who scored the highest!
⏱️

Timed Plan (25 Minutes Total)

3m
Step 1

Hand out the cards and explain rules.

2m
Step 2

Pair up students & assign roles.

7m
Step 3

Round 1: Call 1 (Furniture Shop).

7m
Step 4

Swap roles. Round 2: Call 2 (Recruiter).

4m
Step 5

Count scores & check Teacher Key.

2m
Step 6

Answer 3 closing questions together.

📞

Roleplay Call Cards

Print & Cut
1
🛋️

CALL 1: FURNITURE SHOP

Scenario: Delayed Sofa Order

CALLER Furniture Shop Representative

You work in a furniture shop. The sofa the customer ordered for a party on the 20th is late, because the factory closed for repairs and has given no new date. You cannot promise a date but can offer free delivery.

LISTENER Angry Customer

You are angry and want it before the 20th.

Required 5-Step Order:
1. Who & Bad News 2. Give News 3. Give Reason 4. Next Steps 5. Listen/Answer
2
💼

CALL 2: RECRUITER REJECTION

Scenario: Job Candidate Refusal

CALLER Executive Recruiter

You are a recruiter. The candidate did not get the job, because another person had more experience; you cannot give details about that person, and the candidate may apply again in six months.

LISTENER Disappointed Candidate

You ask why and who got the job.

Required 5-Step Order:
1. Who & Bad News 2. Give News 3. Give Reason 4. Next Steps 5. Listen/Answer
📋

Caller Checklist (5-Step Structure)

1

Identify & Signal

Say who you are and state clearly that you have bad news.

2

Deliver News

Give the unwelcome news directly without sugarcoating.

3

State Reason

Give the objective reason clearly, without blaming anyone.

4

Next Steps

Explain what happens next or present available options.

5

Listen & Answer

Listen patiently with empathy and answer the listener's questions.

🏆

Peer Assessment & Scoring Sheet

Instructions for Listener: Tick off each criteria as your partner performs the call. Calculate final points at the end of the round.

Category Criteria Details Max Score
1. Order Steps 1 point per completed step in the correct 5-step checklist order. 5 pts
2. Grammar Frames 1 point per correct refusal frame used accurately (max 3):
have no choice/option but to, be in no position to, do nothing but.
3 pts
3. Vocabulary Bonus 1 bonus point per Unit word used naturally:
rejection, suspension, reduction, rescind, empathy, reluctant, bluntly, unwelcome, unavoidable, compassionate.
1 pt / word
💬

Sentence Starters

Prompt 1

"I am reluctant to inform you that we have no choice but to delay your order..."

Prompt 2

"Because of an unavoidable delay at the factory, we are in no position to confirm a delivery date..."

Prompt 3

"I understand this unwelcome news causes frustration, but there is nothing we can do but offer free delivery..."

Prompt 4

"I am sorry to give you this rejection, but we have little option but to choose a candidate with more experience..."

Prompt 5

"While I feel deep empathy, I am in no position to disclose confidential applicant details..."

Prompt 6

"To speak bluntly, we cannot rescind this decision, but you may apply again in six months..."

🔑

Teacher Key (Model Answers)

Call 1 Model Furniture Shop

"I am afraid your sofa will be late. The factory closed for repairs, so we have no choice but to wait for it; I am in no position to promise a new date, but delivery will be free."

✔ Gives the news, the reason and what happens next (steps 2-4), with two refusal frames. The caller adds step 1 (who you are) and step 5 (listen and answer).
Call 2 Model Recruiter Rejection

"I am sorry to say you did not get the job. Another person had more experience, and I am in no position to tell you more about them; you may apply again in six months."

✔ Gives the news, a reason without blame and what happens next (steps 2-4), and keeps the other person's details private.
⚠️

Common Grammar Error to Check:

❌ WRONG FORM: "We have no choice but delivering..."
✅ CORRECT FORM: "We have no choice BUT TO DELIVER..." (after no choice but we always need to + base verb).

🔀

Classroom Activity Variations

Level 1: Easy

Help Sheet

Callers may hold and look directly at the Sentence Starters prompt sheet during the call.

Level 2: Medium

Standard Memory

Callers only see scenario details on their card; no sentence starters allowed during call.

Level 3: Hard

Pushback Challenge

The Listener interrupts aggressively with unexpected angry objections and financial demands.

Fast Groups

Improv Call 3

Create Call 3 on the spot (e.g., flight cancellation due to weather or last-minute salary reduction).

❓

Closing Questions (Class Debrief)

1

Polite Frames

Which frame helped you sound polite while saying no?

2

Empathy

How did showing empathy change the way the listener reacted?

3

No Blame

Why is it better to give the reason without blaming anyone?

Related lessons