C1CEFRSpeaking25 min

Class activity: The Refused Claim Hearing

Appealing an official decision

Add to my libraryFree for teachers. You sign in only when you add the lesson.

Answers and an explanation for each question appear once you add this activity to your own library.

Level C1 25 Minutes Pair Activity

The Refused Claim Hearing

Unit: Appealing an Official Decision | Oral Debate & Formal Letter Writing

⚖️
📘

Rules of the Game

👨‍🏫

Teacher Setup & Delivery

  1. 1 Set up pairs and hand out Officer and Applicant cards to each pair.
  2. 2 Explain that Applicants must challenge the £300 deposit deduction using photo evidence.
  3. 3 Monitor the 6-minute oral hearing rounds, ensuring formal reaction structures are spoken.
  4. 4 Guide students to complete the short formal letter writing phase (5 minutes).
  5. 5 Award scores using the checklist and verify outcomes against the Teacher Key.
🎓

Student Instructions

  1. 1 Goal: Win the appeal or justify the deposit refusal using your card details.
  2. 2 Round 1: Oral hearing - state your grounds, present evidence, and request a reconsideration.
  3. 3 Write a short formal letter using unit vocabulary and grammar frames.
  4. 4 Swap roles for Round 2 so both partners experience both roles.
  5. 5 Earn points for frame usage, evidence, deadlines, and bonus unit vocabulary.
⏱️

Timed Plan (25 Minutes)

2m

Step 1

Hand out the cards and explain roles.

3m

Step 2

Applicants prepare grounds; Officers review evidence rules.

6m

Step 3

Run Hearing 1 (Oral debate & photo evidence exchange).

5m

Step 4

Applicants write short formal appeal letter; Officers score performance.

6m

Step 5

Swap roles and play the hearing again.

3m

Step 6

Tally final scores and share the Teacher Key outcome.

⚖️

Officer Card

#1
Parkside Lettings Official
Your letter says: "We regret to inform you that we will keep 300 pounds of your deposit for a damaged carpet."

Your file has 2 move-out photos of the carpet and none from move-in. You may return the money only if the tenant shows that the carpet was already worn at move-in. You can promise a reply within 10 days.

ROLE: HOUSING OFFICER PARKSIDE LETTINGS
⚖️

Applicant Card

#2
Tenant Appeal (Ms Costa)
You left the flat on 1 June. The carpet was already worn when you arrived, and you took a photo on the first day.

Say your grounds, ask the officer to reconsider the decision, and ask for a reply by 15 June. Then write it as a short formal letter.

ROLE: APPLICANT TENANT: MS COSTA
📋

Hearing Checklist

____ Stated legal/factual grounds for objection clearly ____ Presented day-one photo evidence ____ Formally requested a reconsideration of the ruling ____ Asked for a reply by a set date (15 June)
✅

Scoring Rules

1 pt

Per grammar frame used correctly (up to 3 pts)

1 pt

For stating the grounds for objection clearly

1 pt

For asking for a reply by a specific date

+1 Bonus

If the formal letter includes both grounds & deadline

+1 Bonus

Per Unit Word correctly incorporated

Unit Vocabulary Bank (1 Point Each)

refusal ruling eligibility objection reconsideration submission overrule ombudsman tribunal uphold
💜

Sentence Starters

Frame 1 (Applicant)

"I was disappointed to learn that £300 was deducted from my deposit, and I do not accept the ruling."

Frame 2 (Officer)

"We regret to inform you that your eligibility for a full refund depends on proof of the carpet's condition."

Frame 3 (Applicant)

"I was surprised to find that no move-in photos were included in the file, which makes the refusal hard to accept."

Frame 4 (Officer)

"I am sorry to have to say that your objection cannot succeed without proof."

Frame 5 (Applicant)

"I regret to have to raise this matter again, but I request an immediate reconsideration."

Frame 6 (Applicant - Earlier Event)

"I was relieved to have kept my day-one photo to support my submission."

🗝️

Teacher Key

📌 Case Hearing Outcome

Ms Costa shows her day-one photo, so the housing officer agrees to reconsider the ruling and promises an official written reply within 10 days, before 15 June.

💬 Target Model Sentences

  • ✓ "I was disappointed to learn that the deposit had been kept."
  • ✓ "I am concerned to find that no move-in photo exists."
  • ✓ "I regret to have to raise this again."

⚠️ Common Grammar Error Alert

Wrong Form: "disappointed to learned"
Correction: Must use infinitive "to learn" (or "to have learned" for something that happened earlier).

🎭

Variations

Easy

Provide a gap-fill letter template for the Applicant and simplified photo evidence prompts for the Officer.

Standard

Full oral hearing roleplay followed by the independent formal appeal letter writing task as designed.

Hard

Officer actively resists the initial claim, so the Applicant must say they will take the case further, for example to an ombudsman.

Fast Groups

The Officer writes a short formal reply that either upholds or overrules the first decision, in 3 minutes.

💬

Closing Questions

1

How did using formal reaction phrases (e.g., 'We regret to inform you') change the professional tone of the hearing?

2

Which unit vocabulary words (e.g., reconsideration, ruling, objection) were most effective in convincing the officer to reconsider?

3

What key piece of evidence ultimately persuaded the officer to reconsider the £300 deposit deduction?

Related lessons