C1CEFRGrammar12 min

Only To, With + Noun + -ing / -ed, and Absolute Clauses

Cultural heritage and the return of artefacts

Add to my libraryFree for teachers. You sign in only when you add the lesson.

Answers and an explanation for each question appear once you add this activity to your own library.

Advanced C1 Grammar

only to, with + noun + -ing / -ed, noun + -ed at the start

Four short patterns for a surprise, a scene, a step that is finished first, and how or where things are.

⏱️ Target Time: 12 minutes

📋 How to use this lesson

Teacher Guide

Project this guide and give learners twelve minutes to work through the patterns and tasks.

Review the rewrite drills together as a group to check punctuation and form.

Learner Guide

Read the four rule boxes first and look closely at the underlined parts in each sentence.

Complete the twelve practice items from top to bottom using the single clue word in brackets.

The 4 patterns to learn

Study each pattern and note how the words fit together.

Rule 1: a surprise ending only to + verb

You do something, but then a surprise happens, often a sad one. Write a comma, then only to and a short verb. Say "only to find", not "in order to find" or "only for finding". It is not for something you wanted on purpose.

• The group travelled to the museum to collect the statue, only to learn that it was on tour.

• They opened the ancient excavation, only to find it empty.

Rule 2: what is going on with + noun + -ing / -ed

This tells what was going on at that moment. Use -ing when the thing is doing the action: "with the museum refusing". Use -ed when something was done to the thing: "with the relic damaged". Do not add was or is: say "with the custodian resisting", not "with the custodian was resisting".

• With the museum refusing to open its files, historians could not trace the vase.

• With the relic damaged during transport, the team stopped.

Rule 3: one thing is done first noun + -ed (at sentence start, no 'with')

Start the sentence with a thing and a done word, like "the paperwork signed". It means that step was finished first. Then the next part tells what happened after. There is no "with" here, and no was: say "the excavation finished", not "the excavation was finished".

• The paperwork signed, the crates were loaded onto the plane.

• The ancestral land claimed, the tribe celebrated.

Rule 4: how things are / where with + noun + describing word / place

This shows how something is or where it is while something else happens. After the noun, put a describing word, like safe or clear, or a place, like back in the village. Do not add an action word: say "with the shrine safe", not "with the shrine was safe".

• With the mask back in its home village, the elders held a small ceremony.

• With the provenance clear, the restitution process began.

A

Type 1: Choose the Correct Sentence

Item 1 (surprise) Rule 1

Choose the sentence that correctly expresses an unexpected, disappointing outcome:

____ The curator opened the vault in order to find that the colonial plunder had vanished ____ The curator opened the vault only for finding that the colonial plunder had vanished ____ The curator opened the vault only to find that the colonial plunder had vanished
Item 2 (doing) Rule 2

Choose the sentence that correctly describes the custodian actively resisting repatriation:

____ With the custodian was resisting repatriation the ministry intervened ____ With the custodian resisting repatriation the ministry intervened ____ With the custodian resisted repatriation the ministry intervened
Item 3 (done) Rule 3

Choose the correct sentence where the excavation was finished before the analysis began:

____ The excavation finished the team examined each ancient relic ____ The excavation completing the team examined each ancient relic ____ The excavation was finished the team examined each ancient relic
B

Type 2: Fill the Gaps

Item 4 (state) Rule 4

With the ancestral shrine [ ... ] from the conflict zone, the community celebrated.

____ was safe ____ safe ____ be safe
Item 5 (before) Rule 3

[ ... ], the gallery arranged the restitution ceremony.

____ The provenance confirmed ____ The provenance confirming ____ Had the provenance confirmed
Item 6 (surprise) Rule 1

The researchers tracked the stolen artefact across three countries, [ ... ] it had been sold privately.

____ with discovering that ____ for discovering that ____ only to discover that
C

Type 3: Rewrite the Sentence

Item 7 (surprise) Rule 1

Rewrite the sentence using an unexpected result pattern with a comma:

"The minister flew to London and then discovered the artefact was missing from the vault."
Type the complete rewritten sentence: ____ (Type your rewrite...)
Item 8 (doing) Rule 2

Rewrite the sentence using with + noun + -ing:

"The ancestral community demanded repatriation, so the directors held an urgent vote."
Type the complete rewritten sentence: ____ (Type your rewrite...)
Item 9 (before) Rule 3

Rewrite the sentence starting with The provenance and no 'with':

"The provenance was fully verified, and then the museum arranged the restitution."
Type the complete rewritten sentence: ____ (Type your rewrite...)
D

Type 4: Correct the Error

Item 10 (surprise) Rule 1

Find and correct the grammatical error in this message to a fellow researcher:

"We queued three hours for the relic exhibit, only for finding that the gallery was locked!"
Type the correct replacement for the 3-word phrase "only for finding": ____ (Type your answer...)
Item 11 (doing) Rule 2

Find and correct the verb error in this message from the archive team:

"With the board refused restitution of the bronze head, the legal team filed an appeal."
Type the single word that should replace "refused": ____ (Type your answer...)
Item 12 (state) Rule 4

Find and correct the preposition error in this field report message:

"With the colonial plunder now in display in capital museums, few scholars asked about origins."
Type the correct 2-word phrase to replace "in display": ____ (Type your answer...)

Why this works: Quick Review

You now know four tools. only to + verb shows a surprise. with + noun + -ing/-ed shows what is going on. noun + -ed shows a step that is finished first. with + noun + describing word/place shows how things are. None of them needs a joining word like because or and.

Related lessons